Monday, February 8, 2016

So what does it all mean?


To be completely honest, I had a hard time discerning the meaning in this book for a while. For some reason, I tend to have some difficulties with more contemporary books like this. Granted, most of the “contemporary” books I read (i.e. my current read, Amy Poehler’s Yes Please) aren’t really written to have any sort of profound meaning…

From what I could gather though, Krauss seems to be suggesting that love isn’t all rose petals and love notes and jewelry and chocolate and tears of joy. Sometimes love hurts us more than it benefits us. Sometimes we struggle to understand or cope with love. Love is complicated. Ultimately, most humans, like the characters in this book, are driven by love (whether that be good or bad).

Going into this book called The History of Love you expect a romantic, The Notebook-esque love story complete with reunions and tears and everyone living happily ever after. Instead you are introduced to characters that all struggle to cope with the loss of love. Even though they all suffered these losses long ago, they are still motivated by the “leftover” love/attachment.  

à Leo is so enthralled with Alma he fails to move on with his life. He spends his life alone, thinking about how things could’ve been, instead of trying to create a new life. His proudest achievement is the book he wrote about falling in love with Alma and he (possibly) has a heart attack when he finds out that it was not in fact lost forever, but published by his friend.

à Alma’s actions are primarily driven by her love for her late father. She reads the books he used to read and even wears his clothes. She is so fascinated by The History of Love because she knows it was very meaningful to her father. Were it not for her love for her father and also her father’s love for the book, she never would’ve gone on this journey to discover the book’s background. Alma’s mother is also affected by the loss of her husband, but her love for him doesn’t really motivate her to do much of anything, it mostly inhibits her. It inhibits her from finding new love and it inhibits her from maintaining a healthy, active lifestyle-she frequently demonstrates serious symptoms of depression such as lying on the couch/in her room for days on end, and lacking motivation to do much of anything like clean or parent.

Krauss focuses not on the joyous, glamorous parts of love but instead the messy, complicated, heartbreaking parts of love. Proving that although humans live for connections/love, sometimes the one thing we live for can dictate (or inhibit) our actions too much for our own good.

Wednesday, February 3, 2016

Reasons why "The History of Love" is not one of my favorite books

I really wanted to like this book. It sounded great, it had great reviews, but for some reason it just fell short of my expectations. And I'm not all that hard to impress when it comes to literature. I enjoy reading and I enjoy a variety of books. I just couldn't bring myself to love this one. Granted I didn't hate it either. It was just okay. Here's a breakdown of some reasons why it just didn't resonate with me.

1) IT'S NOT A LOVE STORY
I'm not sure why this one bugged me so much but you'd think in a book titled "The History of Love" there'd be some love. Aside from Leo's flashbacks to when he was dating Alma, this book is not really about the beauty and joys of love. It's about losing love and dysfunction in love. Leo never finds love after Alma Mereminski. He also never gets to really love or parent his son. Alma Singer's mom never finds love after her husband dies. Alma awkwardly almost finds love in Misha and later Herman but both turn out to be dead ends. I feel Krauss should've expanded more upon love, whether that be in Leo's past or in Alma's present/future, instead of sheer sadness and loneliness with no resolution or improvement.

2) The ending 
After all of the buildup and confusion, the ending was underwhelming and abrupt. It felt as though Krauss just gave up on writing the book. Alma Singer and Leo end up being connected by Bird, which seemed random and unrealistic. They meet in a park, establish that Leo wrote the book, hug, and then Leo possibly has a heart attack? It felt shallow and anticlimactic in comparison to the complexity of the story. I was expecting them to cross paths in his son's house when they both visited but Krauss overlooked that and dragged the book on far longer than needed. I can't really explain what I was expecting from the ending, but I was expecting more than what we were given. I was hoping at least maybe some sliver of happiness but... no because

3) There is no happiness in this book whatsoever
The characters are very well developed and differentiated but they're all so sad. It was very hard for me to read in that aspect. It was one of the most depressing books I've ever read.

4) There are a lot of loose ends 
I think Krauss just tried to do too much with this book, there were just far too many leads with no follow up or closure whatsoever. In the beginning, it appears Alma is primarily serving as a matchmaker for her mother, but Krauss quickly and abruptly drops this concept. One day Alma is writing letters to Jacob Marcus (who also just kind of disappears), the next she's completely forgotten about her mother's love life. Alma kind of figures out she's in love with Misha but he's suddenly phased out for the rest of the book. Alma's uncle comes to visit for a few weeks and then disappears without contributing much of anything. Misha is described as believing he is the Jewish Messiah but there is no focus on his character until he randomly becomes a narrator for the last few chapters of the book. All of these fragments of the story that Krauss just abandons contribute to how confusing this book can be.

5) It is really confusing 
Between all of the narrators and their connections, the flashbacks, the lists and charts, the history of "The History of Love", this book is at times chaotic. This lead to a lot of confusion and frustration on my part. Again, I think this connects to the fact that Krauss just tried to do too much. You would probably have to read this book at least twice to really understand and appreciate the story.


Although Krauss' writing is overall quite beautiful and poetic, due to the chaos, the abrupt ending, and the overall morose tone, I just couldn't bring myself to love it. However, if you can either dedicate the time to read this book multiple times or you're able to overlook some of these little glitches, this book is definitely worthwhile.